Agnipath Scheme

Agnipath Scheme

The Agnipath Scheme, introduced by the ruling government in June 2022, has sparked considerable opposition from various political parties and military veterans. Concerns continue to grow about its impact on military recruitment and the well-being of soldiers.

What is the Agnipath Scheme?
Overview:
The term Agniveer, meaning "Fire Warriors," represents a new category of recruits within the Indian Armed Forces. Under this scheme, non-officer personnel such as soldiers, airmen, and sailors are enlisted for a fixed period of four years. After this period, up to 25% of these recruits may be offered a permanent role based on their performance and the organization's needs. Currently, all branches except for the medical cadre's technical unit recruit under this scheme.

Eligibility:

Candidates aged between 17.5 and 23 years are eligible, with the upper age limit extended from 21. Both men and women under this age bracket can apply, though there is no gender-specific reservation.

Pay & Benefits:

• Death in Service: Families of Agniveers who die in service are entitled to a financial package of Rs 1 crore, covering both the Seva Nidhi and the deceased's unserved salary.
• Disability Compensation: Agniveers injured during their service may receive compensation up to Rs 44 lakh, depending on the severity of the disability. However, compensation is only available if the disability is caused or aggravated by military duties.
• Pension: Agniveers do not receive a pension after completing the four years, unlike traditional soldiers. Only the 25% who are selected for permanent commission will be eligible for a pension.

Objectives of the Agnipath Scheme

• Youthful and Agile Forces: The scheme aims to create a more dynamic military by focusing on younger recruits, which could lead to improved response times and adaptability in combat situations. The average age of personnel in the armed forces, which is currently 32 years, is expected to decrease to 26 years with Agnipath’s implementation.
• Cutting Pension Expenditure: One key objective of Agnipath is to manage the growing defense pension burden. The Indian Armed Forces' pension bill, projected to reach Rs 2.5 lakh crore by 2025, could be reduced with shorter service durations.
• Technological Integration: The scheme aims to harness the tech-savvy nature of younger recruits to facilitate the integration of emerging technologies into the military.
• Post-Service Civilian Employment: The government anticipates that Agniveers will acquire skills and discipline during their service that will help them secure employment in the civilian sector, contributing to a more skilled workforce and economic growth.
• Job Creation: Agnipath could potentially offer more job opportunities for youth by providing valuable experience and skills during their service.

Similar Programs in Other Countries Several nations have implemented systems similar to the Agnipath Scheme.
For example:

• Voluntary Duty in the U.S.: Military service terms in the U.S. can range from 6 to 9 months, depending on the branch.
• Conscription: Countries like Israel, Norway, and Singapore use conscription, requiring mandatory military service for all citizens.

Issues Associated with the Agnipath Scheme

• Lack of Long-Term Benefits: The scheme provides Agniveers with a one-time payout of Rs 11.71 lakh after completing their four-year service, but they do not receive pension or gratuity benefits, leading to dissatisfaction among recruits who expect long-term job security.
• Short Service Duration: The four-year tenure is criticized for being too brief. Many argue that this period is insufficient for instilling the same level of training, experience, and motivation as full-time soldiers, potentially leading to a skills gap in the armed forces.
• Age Limit Concerns: The current upper age limit of 23 excludes many young people who were unable to enlist due to delays during the pandemic.
• Unemployment Fears: With only 25% of recruits being considered for permanent positions, there is concern that the scheme may worsen India's already high youth unemployment rate.
• Political Motives: Critics argue that the scheme was rushed through without adequate consultation, possibly driven by political considerations ahead of elections. The lack of support from defense veterans has fueled skepticism about its effectiveness.
• Focus on Financial Savings: The scheme's design is viewed by some as primarily aimed at reducing the growing defense pension bill, possibly at the expense of the long-term development of the military.

Proposed Solutions for Agnipath's Future

• Extension of Service Duration and Permanent Retention Rate: It is recommended that Agniveers serve for a period of 7-8 years. Moreover, the retention rate for permanent roles should be increased from 25% to around 60-70%.
• Improved Benefits and Entitlements: Agniveers should be granted access to a contributory pension scheme, more substantial gratuities, and ex-gratia payments for disabilities incurred during service. They should also be provided with preferences for government roles and opportunities in other security forces.
• Robust Reskilling Programs: Comprehensive skilling programs should be developed in partnership with the private sector and government organizations to help Agniveers transition smoothly to civilian life. A law mandating their absorption by private companies could further support this transition.
• Raising Educational Standards: To raise the quality of recruits, the educational requirements for Agniveers should be enhanced from 10th to 12th grade. Furthermore, a more rigorous national entrance examination should be introduced to select the best candidates.

Key Takeaways
The Agnipath scheme marks a significant shift in India’s defense recruitment strategy, aiming to modernize the military while addressing the growing pension liabilities. While it offers benefits like youth-focused recruitment and post-service employment opportunities, it also faces substantial criticism, particularly regarding the lack of long-term job security and financial benefits. A balanced approach, focusing on both the well-being of recruits and the nation’s defense needs, will be essential for the success of this ambitious reform.

Mind Sprint