India's Carbon Market: Paving the Way for a Sustainable Future

As COP-29 takes place in Baku, Azerbaijan, carbon finance and credit systems have become key topics of debate between developed and developing nations. India, having updated its Nationally Determined Contributions in 2023, is set to build its own domestic carbon market. However, global experiences point to two major challenges: safeguarding the credibility of carbon credits to avoid greenwashing and ensuring compliance with international standards, especially those outlined in Article 6 of the Paris Agreement.

What Are Carbon Credits?
Overview:
Carbon credits are tradable certificates that represent the reduction or removal of one metric ton of greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions from the atmosphere. These credits can be transferred to buyers who "retire" them to help meet their climate goals.
Certification and Units:
Carbon credits are typically certified by governmental bodies or independent organizations, ensuring the verified reduction or removal of GHGs. Each credit represents one metric ton of CO₂ or its equivalent (CO₂e). Unlike "offsets," which are often used in voluntary markets, "carbon credits" is the standard term in compliance and voluntary reporting frameworks. To quantify the environmental impact, GHGs are measured in CO₂-equivalents (CO₂e) using 100-year Global Warming Potentials (GWPs) to standardize emissions across different gases.

Opportunities for India in Developing a Domestic Carbon Market

1. Economic Growth and Job Creation
   • Market Expansion and Revenue Generation: India is already a key player in the global carbon credit market, having issued 278 million credits between 2010 and 2022, contributing to 17% of the global supply. This provides a foundation for further growth in the carbon market, creating avenues for new industries, such as carbon verification agencies, green finance firms, and environmental consultancies.
   • Job Creation: A developed carbon market could create over 200,000 new jobs, providing significant support to India’s ambition of becoming a $5 trillion economy while fostering sustainable development.
2. Global Leadership in Climate Action
   • Shaping Global Climate Finance: As the third-largest emitter of greenhouse gases and a leader in renewable energy, India has the opportunity to use its domestic carbon market to influence the global climate finance framework.
   • Climate Diplomacy: India’s leadership in initiatives like the International Solar Alliance illustrates its capacity to guide international climate efforts. The carbon market can enhance India's role in global climate discussions, especially within coalitions of developing nations, while promoting South-South cooperation and technology transfer.
3. Boosting Industrial Innovation and Competitiveness
   • Promoting Industrial Modernization: Carbon pricing within the market can incentivize industries to modernize, encouraging investment in energy efficiency, much like the European Union Emissions Trading Scheme (EU ETS) which helped cut industrial emissions by 41% since 2005.
   • Supporting Clean Technology Development: This market could drive the development of indigenous technologies for hard-to-decarbonize sectors, such as cement and steel. Successful cases, like JSW Steel’s carbon reduction projects, highlight India’s potential to become a leader in low-carbon industrial solutions.
4. Leveraging Digital Technology for Market Efficiency
   • Utilizing Digital Infrastructure: India’s established digital infrastructure, exemplified by initiatives like UPI and COWIN, presents an opportunity to create efficient and transparent carbon markets.
   • Technological Innovation: Incorporating technologies like blockchain, IoT, and AI could improve carbon credit verification and trading, reducing transaction costs and enhancing transparency, positioning India as a frontrunner in digital climate solutions.
5. Attracting Green Investment
   • Boosting Green Finance: A well-functioning carbon market could channel international green finance into sustainable projects, such as renewable energy, energy efficiency, and forest conservation.
   • Supporting ESG Investments: As environmental, social, and governance (ESG) investments rise globally, India’s carbon market could offer a structured avenue for these investments, providing the capital necessary for green projects and complementing initiatives like green bonds.
6. Transforming Rural Economies and Agriculture
   • Carbon Credits in Agriculture: Rural India stands to benefit from carbon markets, particularly through agricultural and forestry carbon credits. Pilot programs in states like Maharashtra have shown that farmers can earn additional income through carbon farming practices, with earnings of up to ₹65,000 per acre annually from forest harvests and carbon revenue, compared to ₹10,000 from traditional farming.
   • Incentivizing Sustainable Practices: Carbon markets can promote sustainable agricultural practices, agroforestry, and rural renewable energy projects, benefiting farmers and bolstering climate resilience and food security.
7. Sector-Specific Opportunities
   • Sectoral Transformation: Carbon markets present distinct opportunities in various sectors, including:
     • Energy: Accelerating the transition to renewable energy.
     • Manufacturing: Funding energy efficiency upgrades.
     • Real Estate: Promoting green building initiatives.
     • Transport: Facilitating the adoption of electric mobility.
   • Proven Market Mechanisms: Programs like the Performance Achieve Trade (PAT) scheme in energy-intensive sectors illustrate industry readiness to engage with market-based carbon reduction mechanisms, opening the door for sector-specific credit systems and trading.
8. Developing a Knowledge Economy
   • Building Expertise: The creation of a domestic carbon market offers the opportunity to build a specialized knowledge economy in carbon accounting, verification, trading, and climate finance.
   • Educational Initiatives: Collaborative efforts such as the Climate University Network, which connects over 100 universities, show the potential for developing academic and professional expertise in the carbon markets, fostering innovation in environmental education and research.
9. Advancing Urban Sustainability
   • Sustainable Urban Development: Carbon markets could support urban sustainability projects, such as waste management, urban forestry, and clean transport.
   • Revenue Generation for Cities: Cities like Indore, which generate revenue through waste carbon credits, demonstrate how the market can incentivize low-carbon infrastructure and create new revenue streams for urban local bodies, helping fund climate-related urban initiatives.

Major Issues Related to the Development of Carbon Market in India

1. Market Design and Pricing Complexity
   • Balancing Environmental and Economic Goals: India faces challenges in creating a market structure that aligns with its environmental targets while ensuring economic feasibility. The complexity lies in determining appropriate emission caps, allocating allowances, and managing market liquidity.
   • Diverse Industrial Landscape: India’s varied industrial base, with differing levels of technological development and emission intensities, makes the application of a uniform pricing system difficult. Furthermore, certain sectors may require protection while still maintaining an effective market.
2. Measurement, Reporting, and Verification (MRV) Infrastructure
   • Data Gaps and Inaccuracies: India’s existing emissions data collection and verification systems are inadequate. Many small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) lack the technical capacity to monitor emissions accurately, further complicating the creation of reliable baseline data.
   • Verifying Emissions Across Sectors: A credible emissions baseline is crucial for market integrity, yet establishing such baselines remains a significant challenge, especially across India’s diverse industrial sectors.
3. Regulatory Framework and Institutional Capacity
   • Regulatory Gaps and Delays: Although the Energy Conservation Amendment Act 2022 was passed, there are still gaps in the regulatory framework, leading to delays in program implementation, such as the Green Credit Programme.
   • Coordination Among Agencies: The coordination needed between various agencies (Bureau of Energy Efficiency, Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change, CERC) to manage carbon market operations adds to the complexity of governance.
   • Capacity Enhancement Needed: Current institutional structures may require substantial upgrades to handle the complexities involved in carbon market operations.
4. Industry Readiness and Compliance Costs
   • Challenges for MSMEs: Many industries, particularly MSMEs, generate substantial carbon emissions but face difficulties in participating due to high compliance costs, including investments in monitoring equipment, verification processes, and trading infrastructure.
   • Technical Capacity Shortfalls: Limited expertise in carbon accounting and trading can place certain sectors at a disadvantage, creating potential market distortions and limiting access for some players.
5. Integration with International Markets
   • Aligning with Global Standards: Aligning India’s domestic carbon market with international standards remains challenging. Ongoing negotiations, such as those under Article 6 of the Paris Agreement, involve complexities in ensuring credit quality while maintaining national sovereignty over carbon assets.
   • Risk of Carbon Leakage: Trade-offs between ensuring competitiveness and reducing emissions must be carefully managed to avoid carbon leakage, where emissions are shifted to countries with less stringent regulations.
6. Double Counting and Additionality Concerns
   • Integrity of Carbon Credits: Double counting—where the same emission reductions are counted multiple times—is a major concern. Recent criticisms of forestry credits, where additionality (whether emissions reductions are truly additional and not business-as-usual) was questioned, point to gaps in verification mechanisms.
   • Multiple Schemes Overlap: India’s multiple existing schemes, such as the Performance Achieve Trade (PAT) and Renewable Energy Certificates, could lead to risks of overlapping credits. Clear protocols for credit ownership and tracking are necessary to maintain market integrity.
7. Regional and Sectoral Disparities
   • Inequity in Market Dynamics: There are significant regional differences in industrial development and technical capabilities across India. States with higher industrial concentrations, like Gujarat, Maharashtra, and Rajasthan, may dominate the carbon market, leaving less developed regions at a disadvantage.
   • Equity Concerns: Ensuring that the benefits of the carbon market are distributed equitably across regions and sectors is crucial to prevent wealth and market opportunities from concentrating in a few areas, while imposing higher costs on less developed regions.
8. Technology and Infrastructure Gaps
   • Inadequate Technological Infrastructure: The current technological infrastructure may not be sufficient to handle the sophisticated operations of a carbon market. Developing secure and reliable carbon trading platforms, along with monitoring and verification technologies, will require substantial investment.
   • Cybersecurity Risks: The digital nature of carbon markets makes them vulnerable to cybersecurity breaches, as demonstrated by past incidents in international registries. Ensuring the safety of market transactions and data is critical.
   • Digital Divide: India’s uneven access to digital technologies across regions and industries could hinder the effectiveness and accessibility of the carbon market, creating operational challenges.
9. Market Manipulation and Speculation Risks
   • Vulnerability to Manipulation: Carbon markets could be susceptible to market manipulation, as seen in some international examples, where offset credits were sold with minimal environmental impact.
   • Greenwashing Concerns: Companies may claim carbon neutrality by using questionable carbon offsets, undermining the market’s credibility and trustworthiness. Ensuring genuine impact from carbon credits is crucial to maintaining the integrity of India’s domestic carbon market.

Measures India Can Adopt to Accelerate the Development of a Domestic Carbon Market

1. Gradual Rollout Strategy
   • Target High-Emission Sectors First: Initiate the carbon market by focusing on major polluting industries like power, cement, and steel, where monitoring infrastructure (such as under the Performance Achieve Trade (PAT) scheme) is already in place.
   • Expand to Other Sectors: Gradually incorporate medium-emission industries as their capacity for emissions monitoring and reporting improves.
   • Learn from Global Successes: This phased approach, similar to China’s successful emissions trading system, ensures a smooth market evolution while enhancing institutional capabilities over time.
2. Unified Digital Infrastructure
   • Centralized Carbon Registry: Develop an integrated platform using blockchain technology to ensure transparent tracking and trading of carbon credits, improving reliability and reducing the risk of fraud.
   • Standardized Digital Reporting: Mandate standardized formats for digital reporting to streamline data across sectors, creating seamless integration via application programming interfaces (APIs).
   • Real-Time Monitoring Systems: Implement real-time emissions tracking with IoT sensors and automated data validation to enhance monitoring accuracy and minimize errors, contributing to a more efficient carbon trading system.
3. Capacity Development and Knowledge Building
   • Carbon Market Skill Development Programs: Establish specialized training programs for industry professionals, auditors, and regulatory bodies to ensure expertise in carbon accounting, verification, and reporting.
   • Certification for Professionals: Develop standardized certification systems for carbon market professionals and verification agencies to establish credibility and uniform standards.
   • Sector-Specific Guidelines: Create customized resources to support emissions calculation and reporting for different industries, fostering consistency across the market.
4. Dynamic Pricing and Stability Mechanism
   • Introduce Price Floors and Ceilings: Implement a pricing mechanism with predefined floor and ceiling prices to avoid sharp price fluctuations, ensuring that carbon prices remain stable and reflective of their environmental value.
   • Market Stability Reserve: Establish a reserve, similar to the European Union Emissions Trading System (EU-ETS), to regulate the supply and demand of carbon credits, preventing market instability.
   • Industry-Specific Allowance Allocations: Design allowance allocation models tailored to different sectors, accounting for technological capabilities and international market competition to ensure fairness and efficiency.
5. Sector-Specific Integration Framework
   • Emission Intensity Benchmarks: Set clear sector-specific benchmarks for emissions reduction and pathways aligned with India’s Nationally Determined Contributions (NDCs).
   • Link Existing Schemes: Integrate the carbon market with existing frameworks like the PAT (Perform, Achieve, and Trade) and Renewable Energy Certificates (REC) to prevent double counting of credits.
   • Hard-to-Abate Sectors Provisions: Establish alternative compliance mechanisms for industries with limited abatement potential, such as steel and cement, and design specialized provisions for them.
   • Create Industry Clusters: Facilitate collaboration through industry clusters that encourage knowledge-sharing, collective efforts, and resource pooling for carbon market participation.
6. International Alignment and Collaboration
   • Conformance with Article 6: Build India’s carbon market infrastructure in alignment with the Paris Agreement’s Article 6, ensuring that it meets international standards for cross-border carbon trading.
   • Bilateral Partnerships: Foster international collaborations for market linking, technology exchange, and capacity-building to enhance market robustness and expand India’s global reach in carbon trading.
   • Framework for International Transfers: Develop clear guidelines for the transfer of international credits and the necessary corresponding adjustments to ensure transparency and credibility in cross-border transactions.
7. Regional Development and Localized Support
   • State-Level Carbon Market Cells: Set up dedicated carbon market cells at the state level to provide localized support, guidance, and monitoring, ensuring that the unique needs of each region are addressed.
   • Tailored Regional Plans: Develop region-specific carbon market development plans based on the industrial profiles of each state, ensuring the market’s equitable growth across the country.
   • Revenue Sharing Mechanisms: Introduce financial incentives, such as revenue-sharing models with states, to encourage active participation in the carbon market and boost regional engagement.

Key Takeaways
India’s carbon market presents a significant opportunity for fostering sustainable growth. By overcoming hurdles such as market structure, data accuracy, and regulatory gaps, India can establish a strong and effective market. This will not only accelerate emissions reductions but also attract green investments, positioning India as a front-runner in global climate leadership.

Mind Sprint