Shaping a Strategic Future in the BRICS Framework

Based on "Why this is not just another BRICS in the wall" published in The Indian Express on 25/10/2024


The 16th BRICS Summit in Kazan, Russia, held under the theme "Strengthening Multilateralism for Just Global Development and Security," emphasized the bloc’s commitment to addressing global challenges. India presented its vision for an expanded BRICS, marking a significant milestone in the organization’s growth. Initially formed in 2006 by Brazil, Russia, India, and China, BRICS aimed to leverage the strengths of these nations while engaging with developed countries. Now including South Africa, Egypt, and the UAE, BRICS reflects its increasing global influence. The Kazan Declaration emphasized non-alignment, intra-BRICS cooperation, and innovative financial solutions, such as promoting local currency trade.

Evolution and Significance of BRICS
Evolution:

  • Membership Expansion: South Africa joined in 2010, broadening BRICS’ representation of emerging economies. In 2024, Egypt, Ethiopia, the UAE, and Iran were added, further expanding its global reach.
  • Key Membership Changes: The inclusion of new members strengthens BRICS’ regional influence and cooperation. The ten member nations now represent over a quarter of the global economy and nearly half of the world’s population.
  • Influence in Energy Markets: The membership of major oil producers like the UAE enhances BRICS’ power in global energy discussions.
  • Institutional Growth: BRICS advocates for reforms in global governance, such as in the UN and WTO, and promotes changes in financial institutions like the IMF and World Bank. It has established the Contingency Reserve Arrangement (CRA) and New Development Bank (NDB) to support financial stability.
Significance:
  • Economic Growth: As of 2023, BRICS accounts for 37% of global GDP and has surpassed the G7 in combined GDP (PPP) and growth rates.
  • Geopolitical Influence: BRICS plays a key role in reshaping global governance and tackling complex international challenges with a consensus-driven approach.
  • Women’s Empowerment: BRICS prioritizes women’s participation in decision-making, supporting initiatives like the BRICS Women’s Forum and Women’s Business Alliance.
  • Urban Development: BRICS promotes affordable housing and urban resilience through the BRICS Urbanization and Municipal Forums, aligned with the 2030 Sustainable Development Agenda.
Significance and Challenges of BRICS for India
Significance for India:
  • Geopolitical Influence: BRICS offers India a platform to balance the China-Russia axis and promote a multipolar global vision. For example, India and China reached a significant agreement on "patrolling arrangements" along the Line of Actual Control (LAC) during the 16th BRICS Summit, facilitating disengagement and resolving tensions.
  • Developmental Financing: Through the New Development Bank (NDB), BRICS has approved 70 projects worth USD 25.07 billion, with India receiving USD 6.9 billion for 18 projects. This strengthens India’s infrastructure development and economic growth while fostering regional cooperation.
  • Voice for Developing Nations: BRICS allows India to amplify its advocacy for the Global South, addressing issues such as fair trade, climate responsibility, and sustainable development, countering policies from developed economies that may hinder emerging markets.
  • Counterterrorism Collaboration: India uses BRICS to highlight counterterrorism concerns, focusing on issues like terror financing and regional security, which are crucial for India’s national interests.
  • Strategic Partnerships with New Members: The inclusion of the UAE and Ethiopia enhances India’s partnerships, particularly in trade, energy, and infrastructure, supporting its regional presence and strategic interests.
Challenges for India:
  • Diverse Member Interests: BRICS includes nations with varying economic systems and political goals, making coordination and consensus challenging. India must balance its priorities with those of countries like China, Brazil, and Russia.
  • China's Dominance: China’s economic influence within BRICS may overshadow India’s role, especially given the growing dependence on Chinese trade and investment. India’s trade deficit with China complicates India’s efforts to assert its economic agenda in the group.
  • Managing Regional Rivalries: BRICS members, such as India and China, have historical rivalries that could hinder group cohesion and complicate decision-making, requiring careful diplomacy from India.
  • Global Governance Model: BRICS faces challenges in developing an inclusive governance model amid global economic uncertainties, trade tensions, and protectionist trends, which can impact the bloc’s effectiveness in promoting stability.

Highlights of the Kazan Declaration from the 16th BRICS Summit

  • Comprehensive Cooperation Framework: The Kazan Declaration reaffirms BRICS’s commitment to mutual respect, sovereign equality, and a fairer global order, setting the stage for enhanced collaboration across sectors for sustainable development and peace.
  • Diplomatic Conflict Resolution: BRICS leaders emphasized resolving the Russia-Ukraine conflict through diplomacy and expressed concern over the humanitarian crisis in Palestine, supporting UN-based mediation efforts and peaceful conflict resolution.
  • Support for G20 and Multilateralism: The declaration highlighted the G20's role in global decision-making, advocating for continued effective functioning based on consensus. BRICS also called for IMF reforms to better reflect the interests of emerging economies.
  • Trade and Dedollarization: BRICS agreed to promote trade in local currencies to reduce reliance on the U.S. dollar, with plans for a gold-backed digital currency. The BRICS Pay system, a decentralized payment platform, will facilitate cross-border finance without relying on Western financial systems.
  • BRICS Grain Exchange: A new initiative for a BRICS Grain Exchange was discussed to enhance market efficiency, food security, and price discovery for grain commodities across member countries.
  • Global Collaboration in Health and Environment: The summit emphasized strengthening health systems, including the BRICS R&D Vaccine Center and disease early warning systems. The declaration also supported India's initiative for an International Big Cats Alliance for wildlife conservation.

Way Forward for India in BRICS

  • Strengthen Diplomatic Engagements: India should foster deeper diplomatic ties within BRICS, bridging national differences to build consensus on trade, climate, and security issues. India must ensure BRICS remains cooperative, not anti-West, advancing a balanced global framework.
  • Enhance Trade and Investment: Expanding trade, particularly with new members like the UAE, will help balance India’s trade deficit with China and diversify its economic partnerships, reinforcing India’s position within BRICS.
  • Promote Multilateral Reforms: India should continue pushing for fairer representation for developing nations in global institutions like the IMF and World Bank, aligning with BRICS’s vision for a more equitable global order.
  • Advance Counterterrorism Cooperation: Strengthening counterterrorism collaboration within BRICS, focusing on financing and radicalization, will enhance collective security and benefit India’s national security goals.
  • Leverage Energy Security: India should strengthen partnerships with energy-rich BRICS members like Russia, focusing on energy infrastructure and renewable energy, to secure long-term energy supplies and ensure sustainable energy security.
  • Support South-South Cooperation: India should use BRICS to drive South-South cooperation, promoting technology transfer, sustainable development, and infrastructure investments, aligning with its vision of a multipolar world.
  • Promote a Balanced BRICS Identity: India must champion a cooperative and inclusive BRICS identity, ensuring it remains a platform for engagement with both Eastern and Western economies, reflecting India’s multi-alignment strategy.
Key Takeaways
BRICS plays a crucial role as a platform for emerging economies to foster economic growth and ensure geopolitical stability. Its importance lies in championing the interests of developing nations. To unlock BRICS's full potential in sustainable development and global equity, it is vital to strengthen diplomatic relations, expand trade ties, and enhance counterterrorism efforts.

Mind Sprint