Valuing Unpaid Labor: India's Hidden Economic Contribution

Valuing Unpaid Labor: India's Hidden Economic Contribution

A recent research paper sheds light on the economic importance of unpaid work, particularly by women, and calls for its recognition in national productivity measures. Unpaid work encompasses a wide range of activities, including caregiving, household tasks, and community services, that contribute significantly to the economy but are not financially compensated. Despite its critical role in supporting the paid workforce, women's unpaid labor remains largely invisible, reinforcing gender inequalities and hindering their access to education and economic independence.

What is Unpaid Work?
 Unpaid work refers to activities, primarily performed by women, that are not compensated financially. These include:

• Domestic Tasks: Household chores like cooking, cleaning, and childcare.
• Care Work: Looking after family members, especially the sick and elderly.
• Community Services: Volunteering and other unpaid work in community settings.
• Subsistence Production: Farming or producing goods for personal use rather than for sale.

Economic Contribution and Gender Disparities
Unpaid labor plays a significant role in the economy, often accounting for a substantial percentage of GDP, particularly in developing countries. However, societal norms dictate that women bear the majority of this burden, limiting their access to paid employment, education, and skill development. This entrenches cycles of inequality, making it difficult for women to achieve economic independence.

The Importance of Valuing Unpaid Work
Recognizing and valuing unpaid work can help combat gender disparities in the workforce and lead to a fairer distribution of domestic responsibilities. Acknowledging this work in national economic accounts, as suggested by the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), can promote gender equality (SDG 5). The SDGs aim to recognize and value unpaid care work by 2030, advocating for policies that share caregiving responsibilities more equally between genders.

Key Findings from the Research
The research uses data from the Consumer Pyramids Household Survey (CPHS) by the Centre for Monitoring Indian Economy (CMIE) to quantify the economic value of unpaid labor.

Key findings include:

• Women spend significantly more time on unpaid domestic tasks, with those outside the labor force dedicating over 7 hours daily, compared to under 4 hours for men.
• The economic value of unpaid household work is estimated to be Rs 49.5 lakh crore (24.6% of GDP) using the Opportunity Cost method, and Rs 65.1 lakh crore (32.4% of GDP) using the Replacement Cost method.

Policy Recommendations
The paper suggests that policies must evolve to recognize and value unpaid labor, thereby fostering gender equity in the workforce. Notably, the System of National Accounts, which measures GDP, currently excludes unpaid care work. It’s essential for future research to refine methods of evaluating unpaid work and promote the fair redistribution of caregiving duties to increase women’s participation in the formal workforce.

Key Statistics on Unpaid Work in India

• According to the Periodic Labour Force Survey (PLFS) 2023-24, 36.7% of females engage in unpaid work within household enterprises, compared to 19.4% of men.
• The National Statistical Office's Time Use Survey 2019 reveals that 81% of women aged 6+ spend over five hours daily on unpaid domestic tasks, with 92% of women aged 15-59 engaging in this labor.
• On average, 26.2% of women aged 6+ spend over two hours daily on caregiving, compared to 12.4% of men.

Global Economic Impact of Unpaid Work
Unpaid work contributes 9% of GDP across APEC economies, totaling USD 11 trillion. The percentage of GDP contributed by unpaid work varies by country, with nations like Australia and Thailand contributing 41.3% and 5.5%, respectively. Why Are Women More Involved in Unpaid Work? Several factors contribute to the disproportionate involvement of women in unpaid work:

• Cultural Norms and Gender Roles: Societal expectations position women as primary caregivers, leading to an unequal burden of unpaid labor.
• Economic Constraints: In many low-income households, unpaid labor by women is seen as a cost-saving strategy.
• Limited Employment Opportunities: Women, especially those with lower education or living in rural areas, often have fewer paid employment options, pushing them into unpaid roles.
• Policy Gaps: The lack of family-friendly policies, such as parental leave and flexible work arrangements, disproportionately affects women and reinforces their role in unpaid labor.

Policies Needed to Address Unpaid Work Inequities To address these disparities, the following policies are necessary:

• Investment in Early Childhood Care and Education (ECCE): Expanding affordable childcare services will allow more women to join the workforce.
• Flexible Work Policies: Companies should adopt flexible work arrangements and paid family leave policies to better support caregivers.
• Legal Frameworks: Implement laws recognizing unpaid care work as a legitimate contribution to the economy and enforce gender equality measures.
• Promoting Shared Responsibility: National campaigns should challenge traditional gender roles and encourage men to take on more domestic responsibilities.

Conclusion
Recognizing and valuing unpaid work, particularly by women, is critical for achieving gender equality and boosting economic productivity. Integrating unpaid labor into national accounts and implementing supportive policies can address gender disparities, empower women, and promote a more equitable and sustainable economy.

Mind Sprint